MODx, Friendly or what?

I have a project it mind that will require a website, while I’m a big fan of Joomla I thought maybe I should use something different and looked at Drupal when someone on twitter (or one of the microblogging sites) suggested I look at MODx.

Now I’d not heard of MODx and seeing as I’m always open to new ideas thought I would take a look. I have to say it looks very good, professional and feels solid. I installed it on a Web Server I have access to which unfortunately is Windows based but that shouldn’t be a problem.

Everything went pretty smoothly and I logged into the Admin area to have a mooch around, this was when I realised that it was nothing like the Joomla I had come to know and love, now I might not use the correct technical terms here so you’ll have to forgive me, it soon dawned on me that I would need fairly advanced coding skills to get MODx to work there does not appear to be any simple “Click here to move/modify the menu” or an idiots way to move anything around. Now I’m not saying that’s a bad thing its probably the right way to do websites but I just don’t have the skill set.

This is where it gets interesting, I posted from Gwibber something along the lines of “I like MODx but it seems a bit advanced for me” which initially produced some positive feedback along the lines of “Join the Forum mush”, “I’ll help you” etc. Which is what Community should be about. Then suddenly it all turned sour when I mentioned Joomla “….Joomla’s unorganized ball of yarn”. Like a fool I tried to defend Joomla which produced further Hate Mail I was going to perpetuate the discussion but decided that discretion was the better part of valor as far as Micro Blogging is concerned and write something here instead (Nobody reads this site other than me anyway).

So while being told Joomla was the spawn of the devil and that I should be burnt at the stake for daring to even look at MODx and bearing in mind I had not said one thing derogatory about MODx I will now vent my spleen.

I have only edited the front page using the built in wysiwig editor other than that I have touched NOTHING!

  1. All the menu links are broken apart from ‘Home’ click on anything and “No such page”
  2. The ‘Preview’ from with Admin doe’s work
  3. If I click on the XHTML validator I have 1 error which the site itself created, is the editor broken?
  4. Click on the CSS Validator and I get 11 errors I’ve not touched anything relating to CSS

I have blacked out some of the URL details so as not to reveal the project I’m planning and for no other reason, the site is still live.

So for the minute I don’t feel like learning how to use the the thing given that I have been given the feeling by people that mere mortals are not welcome especially those that use Joomla.

Loading Facebook Comments ...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *